Polly's Pies: Baked Fresh Daily

Last updated 8 months ago

At Polly’s, we believe every meal should end with a slice of freshly baked pie. That’s why our family restaurant bakes our amazing selection of pies in-house every day. We start every pie recipe with the best ingredients and a homemade flaky pie crust. Here’s just a sampling of some of the pies that have customers flocking to Polly’s:

Banberry
Banberry pie is a signature Polly’s creation. We start off with a base of our famous banana cream pie, and then we cover it in ripe strawberries. A ring of real whipped cream is the final touch to this rich and sweet one-of-a-kind pie.

Uncle Eddie’s Signature Apple Pie Delight
Polly’s deep-dish apple pie is a delight in itself, but for a real treat, you should consider eating it like Uncle Eddie. To create this favorite, we take a warm piece of our apple pie and top it off with a generous scoop of old-fashioned vanilla ice cream. To finish it off, we drizzle warm caramel sauce all over the top.

Southern-Style Pecan Pie
Take a journey to the South with this classic Southern-style pie. This gooey mixture of fresh pecans, butter, and sugar tastes rich and nutty and is sure to satisfy even the most demanding sweet tooth.

Polly’s Gourmet Coffee Pie
Our freshly baked pies pair perfectly with our in-house roasted coffee, which inspired us to create this pie. The base of the pie is cream made from our Kona-roasted coffee. We then add macadamia nuts, toasted coconut, and Hershey’s chocolate syrup. It’s the perfect way to enjoy even more of the Polly’s coffee you love.

We have a freshly baked pie for every occasion at Polly’s Pies! Stop by today to enjoy a slice in our family restaurant or pick up a whole pie to-go from our in-house bakery. To find out about our pie selection, including any special pies we currently have on offer, call us at (714) 459-5488.